Schrödinger’s pension

In 1935 Erwin Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment to show the absurdity of the idea of quantum superposition. This was the idea that a particle could, until the point at which it is ‘observed,’ be in two mutually exclusive states at once. By imagining a sealed box with a mechanism that relied on this phenomenon, he was pointing out that this mathematical artefact of very small-scale particles couldn’t be how things really worked at the scale of domestic cats. Otherwise, we would have to accept that a cat could be in some sense alive and dead at the same time.

Last month we looked at the McCloud Remedy, a feature of the UK pension system that has had an impact on a great number of public sector workers. As a result of an act of age discrimination on the part of the government, many younger workers have had their NHS, Armed Forces, Police, Fire Service, Judicial, Teachers, Local Government or Civil Service pension mucked about with. This has added complexity to something that already requires a bit of dedication to understand properly.

Different organisations have made different decisions about how to correct the age discrimination. As a result, there is now a confusing patchwork of oddities applying to the various schemes. I’m going to run through a few of them.

For most public sector schemes, workers who haven’t yet retired only get to choose which scheme their 2015–2022 service counts for when they finally do so. The Deferred Choice Underpin (DCU) is the official term for this mechanism and it creates a slightly absurd superposition of pension states that would have annoyed Schrödinger as much as quantum superposition.

Take an NHS worker, who could have a pension in two different schemes snappily titled ‘The 1995/2008 Scheme’ (composed of the 1995 section and 2008 section) and ‘The 2015 Scheme’. Each has different retirement dates, different rules for accrual, different rules about lump sums and different rules about deferring your pension. Those with careers that run through 2015–2022 will now get an option about which scheme those years were accrued in. This can make a big difference depending on your circumstances.

The biggest factor is the retirement age. In the 1995 section you can take the pension at 60. For younger members in the 2015 Scheme, retirement is at age 68. If you were a consultant or senior manager earning £100,000 per annum during those years you could receive around £96,000 from the 1995 section by the time you reach 68. But the 2015 Scheme pays a bigger pension later, so the longer you live the more of that you make back. If you live long enough, there is a crossover point where you would have been better off taking the higher income later rather than a lower income 8 years earlier. That is a difficult judgement to make and best made in the context of someone’s wider circumstances.

The British public are often accused of being mean-spirited towards higher earners. Personally, I find this accusation usually comes from members of the British public themselves. The trait on display is an enthusiasm for the sport of self-flagellation more than a resentment of the hard-working or successful. But one group of people we certainly like to see earning well are doctors. So much so that the rules that remove pension tax relief for higher earners were specifically modified to accommodate senior consultants who were having to pay out of pocket for the pension they were building up in the NHS scheme. Consultants were finding that they had to pay HMRC something called an ‘Annual Allowance Charge’ for paying too much into a pension. Because they were in a defined benefit scheme there was no cash changing hands when paying in; that meant there was nothing to reduce. But there was cash required to pay the tax bill to HMRC each year. That was painful and the only thing those affected could do to avoid the tax bill was work less. So they did.

There is one part of Schrödinger’s pension where the box has already been opened: tax. For annual allowance purposes, everyone affected has been put back into the old scheme for the McCloud years, whatever they eventually choose. The allowance then was generally £40,000 a year, and that recalculation can mean a rebate on charges already paid, or a new bill where there wasn’t one. Because the old final salary schemes keep growing with your pay, the knock-on effects can also reach how much you can pay into a pension today.

Correcting everyone’s pension records is taking time, the NHS is one of the world’s largest employers after all. But it has a practical cost. Schemes only send an annual allowance statement automatically if you’ve breached the allowance. That is no help to someone in their final years of work who wants to build up a private pension to bridge the gap to their scheme’s pension age. To use carry forward, they need to know how much of the last three years’ allowance their NHS pension has used up, and until their record has been recalculated on the old-scheme basis, nobody can tell them accurately. Their tax position is still in the box.

Other schemes have similar arcane specificities. Judges were required to make a one-time election, with the Ministry of Justice compensating judges for any resulting tax. For those in the police, military and fire service the early retirement ages (or a lack of retirement age in some schemes) have meant decisions come earlier than one might expect.

The Local Government Pension Scheme does things differently. It moved to career average a year earlier, in 2014, and protected older members with an underpin: a guarantee that their pension would be no lower than under the old final salary rules. The Remedy simply extends that underpin to younger qualifying members, automatically. There is no choice to make, and for most people it makes little difference. The Universities Superannuation Scheme is not affected at all; it looks like a public sector scheme but is legally a private one.

These details can be baffling. I often see people defer decisions about their workplace pensions simply because it is so hard to understand what the options are and how to assess them. Avoiding the issue can be risky too though. There are defined benefit pensions that pay no uplift if you take them after normal pension age. If you leave yours untouched, you may simply be leaving money on the table.

This begs the question of why pensions are so complicated in the first place. Ultimately the system must be maintained and adapted to a changing world. That means changing the rules from time to time. This is usually done so as not to change the situation for existing pensioners and the benefits that have already been built up. Pensions are therefore a series of overlapping political settlements, like layers in an archaeological dig, that correspond to different time periods. That makes for some maddening features that can feel as counterintuitive as quantum theory and undead cats. But the alternative is that the interests of certain groups, like the younger workers who were discriminated against between 2015 and 2022, are simply disregarded.

If you would like a second pair of eyes on your statements or your choice, you can get in touch here.

Next
Next

A deal undone